Skip to content
IoTronix Solution

Manufacturing ERP Malaysia: Price vs Factory Apps vs Excel

Published · 7 min read · IoTronix Solution

In short

A manufacturing ERP handles the office work of a factory: accounts, sales orders, purchasing and stock. Published Malaysian prices start at RM200 a month for an off-the-shelf cloud ERP. A custom ERP costs RM28,000 to RM150,000 or more [1][2]. An ERP does not track machine run and stop, downtime reasons or scrap. So many SME factories start with one production floor app, and add an ERP later when the office needs it.

What a manufacturing ERP does well

An ERP is software that manages a company's main business processes in one system [5]. In a factory, this means the office work: the general ledger, payables and receivables, sales order entry and pricing, purchasing from suppliers, stock in the store and, in a manufacturing ERP, the bill of materials and work orders [5].

This is where an ERP is worth the money. It keeps one record for each customer order, from quotation to invoice. Stock valued the same way every month. Purchase orders that match the bill of materials. If your accountant, sales team and store clerk all use different Excel files, an ERP is the right solution.

What an ERP cannot track on the production floor

An ERP knows what was planned. It does not know what each machine is doing now. On a typical injection moulding or extrusion floor, these numbers never reach the ERP by themselves:

  • Run and stop. Which machine is down at 3pm, and since when.
  • Downtime reasons. Mould change, material shortage, no operator, breakdown. Operators round off the times or do not record short stops.
  • Scrap at the machine. Rejects are written on paper and typed in at the end of the shift, or not at all.
  • Shift handover. Work the night shift left half done is only recorded in a notebook or a WhatsApp group.

In the standard factory model (ISA-95), the ERP sits at the business level and a manufacturing execution system (MES) sits between the ERP and machine control [6]. The ERP sends orders down, and the MES sends back what was actually produced and consumed [6]. Without this middle layer, a supervisor types the production numbers into the ERP by hand, hours late.

What ERP costs in Malaysia: published prices

Published Malaysian ERP prices start at RM200 a month for a cloud ERP. A custom ERP costs RM28,000 to RM150,000 or more [1][2]. Most vendor top 10 lists do not show prices. These are figures vendors publish on their own pages. They are the vendors' claims, not our measurements. A real quote depends on your number of users, modules and data migration.

  • Off-the-shelf cloud ERP: Ecount lists RM200 a month with unlimited users, covering sales, purchasing, inventory, production, accounting and payroll [2].
  • Custom ERP, one-time: CloudHouse, a custom ERP developer, says a custom build typically costs RM28,000 to RM150,000 or more before any grant [1]. Its entry package is RM28,000 and its mid package RM68,000, excluding SST [1].
  • Custom ERP as a subscription: the same vendor lists SaaS pricing from RM1,800 a month [1].
  • Three-year cost: CloudHouse puts its own work at RM40,000 to RM180,000 over 3 years, and large brand-name ERP at RM600,000 or more with 9 to 16 months to go live [1].

The licence is the smaller part of the cost. The bigger cost is staff time. Your clerk and accountant spend weeks cleaning item codes, setting up the bill of materials and learning new screens. And the factory must keep running at the same time.

ERP vs ready-made factory apps vs Excel

Short answer: an ERP tracks the office, factory apps track the production floor, and Excel only shows what one person typed in.

ERPReady-made factory apps (FactoryOS)Excel
What it coversAccounts, sales orders, purchasing, stock valuation, bill of materials [5]One floor process per app: breakdown reports, production reports, OEE, maintenance, material requests, shift handoverWhatever the person who built the file decided
Sees machine run and stopNo, unless fed by an MES or machine data [6]Yes, with machine connection: our sensors work on old machinesNo
Typical start costFrom RM200 a month (cloud) or RM28,000 one-time (custom) [1][2]Starter RM3,000 for one app; customised modules from RM8,000; subscription from RM90 a month per 5 usersThe licence you already have
Time to first valueVendor claims run from 4 weeks for one custom module to 9 to 16 months for large ERP [1]One app live in 2 weeksToday, until the file owner goes on leave
Who runs itAccounts, sales and store, with someone who owns the master dataSupervisors, technicians and clerks on phones and tabletsOne person who knows the formulas

Maintenance is often missing from both ERP and Excel. A CMMS (computerised maintenance management system) is software that keeps a database of a site's maintenance work, tasks and spare parts [7]. Many owners searching for CMMS software in Malaysia only need three things first: breakdown reports, a maintenance schedule and a spare parts list. FactoryOS has ready-made apps for each.

Can the SME Digitalisation Grant pay for it?

Partly. The grant pays 50% of the invoice, up to RM5,000. ERP is one of the eligible service types [3][4]. The Geran Digital PMKS MADANI (GDPM) is run by BSN with MDEC and MCMC for the Ministry of Finance [4]. As BSN publishes it:

  • It matches 50% of the invoice, up to RM5,000 per eligible business [3][4].
  • Nine service types qualify, including ERP and accounting, AI, and smart systems [4]. A business can apply for up to 3 types, with appointed digital service providers [4].
  • The business must be registered with SSM or a local authority, at least 60% owned by Malaysians, operating for at least 6 months, with average yearly sales of at least RM50,000 [4].
  • Businesses that received an earlier digitalisation matching grant are not eligible, except for e-invoicing [4].
  • Applications go through Funding Societies, appointed by MDEC, and grants depend on the allocation available [4].

Some vendor pages quote much larger grant tiers. BSN's own FAQ limits this grant to RM5,000 per business [4]. So for a RM28,000 custom ERP, it only covers a small part. Ask the grant administrator two questions. Is the product, including FactoryOS, on the appointed provider list? And is a round open now? Check with BSN or MDEC before you sign.

Which one to choose

Choose based on where your main problem is. Choose an ERP for office problems. Choose one factory app for production floor problems. Stay on Excel if you still check the production floor yourself every day.

  1. Choose an ERP first when the pain is in the office: invoices, e-invoicing, stock valuation, customer orders across many products. Make sure one person will own the master data.
  2. Start with one factory app when the pain is on the floor: you call the supervisor to know today's output, breakdowns are reported by WhatsApp, the production report arrives the next day. Pick the process that hurts most and have it live in 2 weeks.
  3. Stay on Excel for now if you run a few machines, one product family and see the floor yourself every day. Fix the file owner problem before you buy anything.
  4. FactoryOS is not for you if you are a large factory already running a full ERP or MES with your own IT team. The same goes for workshops under 20 staff.

Not sure if you need an ERP, a custom app, or a link to the ERP you have?

Book a free 30-minute Factory Paperwork Check. We visit your factory, show you your 3 most time-wasting processes and tell you clearly which one fits: a custom app instead of a full ERP, or your machines connected to the ERP you already run.

Questions

How much does an ERP system cost in Malaysia?

Published prices start at RM200 a month for an off-the-shelf cloud ERP [2]. One custom ERP developer quotes RM28,000 to RM150,000 or more, paid one time [1]. Ask every vendor for the total cost over 3 years, including installation and training.

Is ERP worth it for a small factory, or should I start with apps?

If your problem is accounts and orders, an ERP is worth it. If your problem is downtime, late production reports or breakdowns on WhatsApp, a full ERP will not track those. It also rarely fits how your factory works. We customise apps and build the machine hardware to fit your factory. You can start with one app at RM3,000, live in 2 weeks.

Excel vs ERP: when should a factory stop using Excel?

Stop using Excel when one person's leave stops a process. Also stop when two files show different stock, or when the production report is always a day late. These signs show the file is too small for your team now.

Can I keep my ERP and add factory apps?

Yes. FactoryOS is not an ERP. It runs next to the ERP you already use and covers the production floor work the ERP cannot track. Keep your machines too. IoTronix can send their data to your ERP by API, scoped after a free site visit.

What is the difference between ERP and MES?

An ERP plans the business: orders, stock and accounts [5]. An MES tracks how raw material becomes finished goods on the production floor. It reports actual output back to the ERP [6].

Can I use the SME Digitalisation Grant for ERP?

Yes. ERP and accounting is one of the nine service types under the Geran Digital PMKS MADANI. It pays 50% of the invoice, up to RM5,000 [4]. The provider must be appointed under the scheme, so check with BSN or MDEC first.

Sources

  1. [1]CloudHouse Technologies. ERP Development Company in Kuala Lumpur
  2. [2]Ecount. Ecount ERP pricing (Malaysia)
  3. [3]Bank Simpanan Nasional (BSN). Geran Digital PMKS Madani (GDPM), 2023-11-17
  4. [4]Bank Simpanan Nasional (BSN). Soalan Lazim (FAQ) berkenaan Geran Digital PMKS Madani (GDPM)
  5. [5]Wikipedia. Enterprise resource planning
  6. [6]Wikipedia. Manufacturing execution system
  7. [7]Wikipedia. Computerized maintenance management system